Welcome to Sugar Hill Pizzeria
At Sugar Hill Pizzeria, located in Kinston, NC, we bring a taste of Italy to the heart of North Carolina. Our story begins with a passion for crafting delicious, authentic dishes that create lasting memories. Customers rave about our classic New York-style pizza, loaded with quality ingredients and generous portions. Highlights include our delectable Fried Ravioli, savory Chicken Wings, and indulgent Loaded Pizza Fries. Conveniently situated near Mother Earth Brewery, diners can enjoy their meals while sipping craft beers, with our friendly staff delivering directly to your table. Join us for a slice of comfort and see why we’re a local favorite!
-
211 N Herritage St, Kinston, NC 28501 Hotline: (252) 686-8800
Welcome to Sugar Hill Pizzeria, the hidden gem of Kinston, North Carolina, where classic Italian flavors meet the warmth of true Southern hospitality. Nestled at 211 N Herritage St, this pizzeria has quickly become a go-to spot not just for locals, but for visitors who crave delicious, mouthwatering pizza in a casual, inviting atmosphere.
Whether you're craving a traditional pepperoni pizza or something a bit more adventurous, Sugar Hill Pizzeria has something for everyone. Their menu boasts an array of delectable dishes, starting with Loaded Pizza Fries and Fried Ravioli that make for the perfect shareable starters. For those looking for a heartier main, you'll want to indulge in their signature Stromboli, which has garnered rave reviews for its generous portions and flavorful fillings.
- Starters:
- Loaded Pizza Fries - $7.49
- Fried Ravioli - $7.49
- Mac & Cheese Bites - $6.49
- Garlic Knots - $4.49
- Salads:
- Caesar Salad - $7.49
- Chef Salad - $8.49
- Wings: Chicken Wings (6) - $11.99
What truly sets Sugar Hill Pizzeria apart is its commitment to quality and convenience. With the Mother Earth Brewery right across the street, it's no surprise that diners have found delight in ordering their pizza and enjoying it with a refreshing brew. The staff will bring your piping hot order right to your table, making it an exceptional dining experience. As Tom B. noted in his review, while he encountered a slight hiccup with an overcooked pizza, the lasagna and Stromboli were “fantastic,” affirming that there’s more to love than just pizza here.
Angles of convenience and quality echo through multiple reviews, with patrons like Coley M. celebrating the friendly staff and perfect customization of orders. The ambiance, while not extravagant, serves its purpose well—clean and efficient, allowing you to grab a bite and dash back to the vibrant brewery scene nearby.
And don't leave without sampling one of their desserts—Donna T. particularly swears by the classic cheesecake and irresistible cannoli. With reasonable prices combined with generous portions, Sugar Hill Pizzeria truly offers an ideal setting for family outings, casual dinners, or busy folks on the go looking to enjoy quality food.
So, whether you’re in Kinston or just passing through, make Sugar Hill Pizzeria a stop on your culinary journey. Their menu might just have the slice of happiness you've been seeking.
For orders or inquiries, you can reach them at (252) 686-8800.
Home delivery this time - pizza was a little overcooked, however lasagna and SHP Stromboli were fantastic! Everything was ready and hot on delivery. Next time I think thick-crust pizza may better meet our mark! Thank you Sugar Hill Pizzaria!
I stopped in because I had a hr wait to charge my car ... I will be back so impressed with the food. I will drive from New Bern to eat here... love it
Service was great and this restaurant is conveniently located across the street from Mother Earth Brewery. Once your order is placed and paid for you can go back to enjoying refreshments at the brewery and Sugar Hill staff will bring your order to you. I found that exceptional and really convenient. We ordered a large peperoni pizza. I wasn't a fan of the crust but everything else on the pizza (cheese, sauce, etc.) was really good.
One of our local favorites! Be sure to grab a dessert too!! My favorite is the steak and cheese sub!! Hard to chose between the cheese cake or cannoli!!!
Great place!! Pizza exactly as we asked for it Been there three times and liked it better each time Great staff just a really good place to eat!!!
Really a 3.5, but rounding up! I enjoyed the pizza! We had classic pepperoni and it's what you'd expect for NY style pizza. A good crust to sauce to cheese ratio. The side salad comes with tomato, cucumber, and onion. Unfortunately mine had several brown pieces. I also missed getting a fork, so I just sprinkled it on top of my pizza, which is actually a classic move of mine. I can't speak much to ambiance since I just ran in to pick up but it was clean and no wait. Tables inside and a few outside. Hubby said it was slightly salty. We did take out, and a small pizza with salad was more than plenty for both of us. About $22. I also love that you can order ahead online. I would totally come back! Especially to walk it across the street to the brewery.
Straight FIRE pizza. Served it up hot and even brought it to us while we were sipping at Mother Earth Brewery. Can't ask for much better than that!
Great spot to grab lunch with the family! We ordered the supreme pizza. It was good could've had a little more sauce & cheese. Otherwise flavor was good! Mother-in-law ordered the window with fries the wings looked and smelled really good. Nephew ordered plain pasta and the Stromboli. Stromboli looked really good too large portions. The dessert was amazing I should've grabbed photos but we ate it too fast for that! We ordered the caramel cheesecake and the Reese's pie. Both were so good!
We like to order a medium pie and head over to Mother Earth taproom with the pie. You can expect a 15-20 minute wait on Friday nights when ordering or coming inside to dine. Plenty of options beside pizza, but that seems to be our go-to choice when visiting.